Pain and Intentionality
Chapter in an edited book (author)


Times Cited
Web of Science2WOS source URL (as at 14/01/2022) Click here for the latest count
Altmetrics Information
.

Other information
AbstractThis paper addresses the oldest controversy in the phenomenology of pain, which concerns the intentional nature of pain experience. First, I present the central reasons that underlie the view that originates in Carl Stumpf’s writings, which suggests that pain is a non-intentional feeling-sensation. Second, I present the evidence that underlies the Brentanian perspective, which suggests that pain is an irreducibly intentional experience. Third, I argue that Edmund Husserl’s schema, “apprehension—content of apprehension,” enables one to reconcile these positions. In this regard, I argue that this schema provides the conceptual basis for defending two claims: (1) pain is an irreducibly stratified phenomenon; (2) while some of its strata are non-intentional, others are marked by intentionality. Fourth, with the aim of demonstrating the philosophical significance of this schema in the framework of phenomenological pain research, I open a brief dialogue between phenomenology and cognitive science. I show how this schema can clarify the experiential structures of lobotomized, cingulotomized as well as morphinized patients as well as how it can shed light on such syndromes as threat hypersymbolia, pain asymbolia and congenital analgesia.
Acceptance Date06/09/2016
All Author(s) ListSaulius Geniusas
All Editor(s) ListRoberto Walton, Shigeru Taguchi, Roberto Rubio
Edition1
Book titlePerception, Affectivity, and Volition in Husserl’s Phenomenology
Series TitlePhaenomenologica
Year2017
Volume Number222
PublisherSpringer
Pages113 - 133
ISBN978-3-319-55338-2
eISBN978-3-319-55340-5
LanguagesEnglish-United States
Keywordsphenomenology, pain, intentionality, Brentano, Stumpf, Husserl

Last updated on 2022-15-01 at 01:03