The Effectiveness of the Production-Oriented Approach to Enhance Adult Chinese EFL Learners’ Language Proficiency: A Comparative Study of Three Language Teaching Approaches
Publication in refereed journal
CUHK Authors
Full Text
Digital Object Identifier (DOI) DOI for CUHK Users |
Times Cited
Altmetrics Information
.
Other information
AbstractThe production-oriented approach (POA) is a nascent language-teaching approach that considers the aptitudes of Chinese learners. This study compared POA with task-based language teaching (TBLT) and presentation-practice-production (PPP) theoretically and empirically. A four-quadrant model and a theoretical comparison table are proposed to clarify the commonalities and differences among the three teaching approaches. In the experimental design, a mixed-method approach was employed to compare the effects of POA with the other pedagogical methods on adult Chinese learners’ English-as-a-foreign language (EFL) learning. A total of 343 Chinese college freshmen and six English teachers were invited to participate in an 18-week pre- and post-test quasi-experiment. The ANCOVA results indicated that the students’ English proficiency test scores (excluding speaking) in the POA group were significantly higher than those in the PPP group (moderate effect size: 0.27) and the TBLT group (small effect size: 0.17), albeit non-significant. MANOVA step-down analysis showed that the POA group significantly outperformed the TBLT and PPP groups in terms of vocabulary acquisition and writing. The implications and suggestions for better dissemination and implementation of POA for adult EFL learners in China and other Asian contexts are discussed.
Acceptance Date27/03/2023
All Author(s) ListQianying Xuan, Alan Cheung, Hongbiao Yin, Xiaoxiao Yu, Ruifang Huang
Journal nameAsia-pacific Education Researcher
Year2024
Month4
Volume Number33
Issue Number2
PublisherSpringer
Pages297 - 306
ISSN0119-5646
eISSN2243-7908
LanguagesEnglish-United States
KeywordsProduction-oriented approach, English-as-a foreign language teaching ,Adult Chinese EFL learners