Attribute weighting methods and decision quality in the presence of response error: A simulation study
Publication in refereed journal


Times Cited
Web of Science93WOS source URL (as at 28/03/2020) Click here for the latest count
Altmetrics Information
.

Other information
AbstractThis paper uses a simulation approach to investigate how different attribute weighting techniques affect the quality of decisions based on multiattribute value models. The weighting methods considered include equal weighting of all attributes, two methods for using judgments about the rank ordering of weights, and a method for using judgments about the ratios of weights. The question addressed is: How well does each method perform when based on judgments of attribute weights that are unbiased but subject to random error? To address this question, we employ simulation methods. The simulation results indicate that ratio weights were either better than rank order weights (when error in the ratio weights was small or moderate) or tied with them (when error was large). Both ratio weights and rank order weights were substantially superior to the equal weights method in all cases studied. Our findings suggest that it will usually be worth the extra time and effort required to assess ratio weights. In cases where the extra time or effort required is too great, rank order weights will usually give a good approximation to the true weights. Comparisons of the two rank-order weighting methods favored the rank-order-centroid method over the rank-sum method. (C) 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
All Author(s) ListJia J, Fischer GW, Dyer JS
Journal nameJournal of Behavioral Decision Making
Year1998
Month6
Day1
Volume Number11
Issue Number2
PublisherJOHN WILEY & SONS LTD
Pages85 - 105
ISSN0894-3257
eISSN1099-0771
LanguagesEnglish-United Kingdom
Keywordsattribute weights; decision quality; multiattribute utility; preference uncertainty; rank-order weights; response error; simulation; uncertain weights
Web of Science Subject CategoriesPsychology; Psychology, Applied; PSYCHOLOGY, APPLIED

Last updated on 2020-29-03 at 01:35