Comparison of disease prevalence in two populations in the presence of misclassification
Publication in refereed journal


Times Cited
Web of Science5WOS source URL (as at 15/01/2021) Click here for the latest count
Altmetrics Information
.

Other information
AbstractComparing disease prevalence in two groups is an important topic in medical research, and prevalence rates are obtained by classifying subjects according to whether they have the disease. Both high-cost infallible gold-standard classifiers or low-cost fallible classifiers can be used to classify subjects. However, statistical analysis that is based on data sets with misclassifications leads to biased results. As a compromise between the two classification approaches, partially validated sets are often used in which all individuals are classified by fallible classifiers, and some of the individuals are validated by the accurate gold-standard classifiers. In this article, we develop several reliable test procedures and approximate sample size formulas for disease prevalence studies based on the difference between two disease prevalence rates with two independent partially validated series. Empirical studies show that (i) the Score test produces close-to-nominal level and is preferred in practice; and (ii) the sample size formula based on the Score test is also fairly accurate in terms of the empirical power and type I error rate, and is hence recommended. A real example from an aplastic anemia study is used to illustrate the proposed methodologies.
All Author(s) ListTang ML, Qiu SF, Poon WY
Journal nameBiometrical Journal
Year2012
Month11
Day1
Volume Number54
Issue Number6
PublisherWILEY-BLACKWELL
Pages786 - 807
ISSN0323-3847
eISSN1521-4036
LanguagesEnglish-United Kingdom
KeywordsDifference between two disease prevalence rates; Partially validated series; Sample size; Score test
Web of Science Subject CategoriesMathematical & Computational Biology; MATHEMATICAL & COMPUTATIONAL BIOLOGY; Mathematics; Statistics & Probability; STATISTICS & PROBABILITY

Last updated on 2021-16-01 at 00:37