A Critical Review of the Ability of Continuous Cardiac Output Monitors to Measure Trends in Cardiac Output
Publication in refereed journal

Times Cited
Web of Science305WOS source URL (as at 10/08/2020) Click here for the latest count
Altmetrics Information

Other information
AbstractNumerous cardiac output (CO) monitors have been produced that provide continuous rather than intermittent readings. Bland and Altman has become the standard method for validating their performance against older standards. However, the Bland and Altman method only assesses precision and does not assess how well a device detects serial changes in CO (trending ability). Currently, there is no consensus on how trending ability, or trend analysis, should be performed. Therefore, we performed a literature review to identify articles published between 1997 and 2009 that compared methods of continuous CO measurement. Identified articles were grouped according to measurement technique and statistical methodology. Articles that analyzed trending ability were reviewed with the aim of finding an acceptable statistical method. Two hundred two articles were identified. The most popular methods were pulse contour (69 articles), Doppler (54), bioimpedance (38), and transpulmonary or continuous thermodilution (27). Forty-one articles addressed trending, and of these only 23 provided an in-depth analysis. Several common statistical themes were identified: time plots, regression analysis, Bland and Altman using change in CO (Delta CO), and the 4-quadrant plot, which used direction of change of Delta CO to determine the concordance. This plot was further refined by exclusion of data when values were small. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to define the exclusion zone. In animal studies, a reliable reference standard such as an aortic flowprobe was frequently used, and regression or time plots could be used to show trending. Clinical studies were more problematic because data collection points were fewer (8-10 per subject). The consensus was to use the 4-quadrant plot with exclusion zones and apply concordance analysis. A concordance rate of >92% when using a 15% zone indicated good trending. A new method of presenting trend data (Delta CO) on a polar plot is proposed. Agreement was shown by the angle with the horizontal axis and Delta CO by the distance from the center. Trending can be assessed by the vertical limits of the data, similar to the Bland and Altman method. (Anesth Analg 2010;111:1180-92)
All Author(s) ListCritchley LA, Lee A, Ho AMH
Journal nameAnesthesia and Analgesia
Volume Number111
Issue Number5
PublisherLippincott, Williams & Wilkins
Pages1180 - 1192
LanguagesEnglish-United Kingdom
Web of Science Subject CategoriesAnesthesiology; ANESTHESIOLOGY

Last updated on 2020-11-08 at 03:34